Debunking Social Media Marketing Myths for 2025

Jump to:

• Myth #1: "If my content is good enough, people will remember my brand.”
  
• Myth #2: “Social media data is just for the marketing team.”
  
• Myth #3: “You can’t measure ROI from social media.”
  
• Myth #4: “Commenting on other people’s posts is cringe or spammy.”
• Myth #5: “Comments don’t impact ad performance.”
  
• Myth #6: “You should avoid controversial topics to protect your brand.”
  
• Myth #7: “Long-form content doesn’t work on social media.”
  
• Myth #8: “Sentiment analysis isn’t accurate enough to be useful for brands.”
• Myth #9: “Reviews don’t matter for social media success.”
  
• Myth #10: “All comments should receive equal attention.”

Myth #1: “If my content is good enough, people will remember my brand.”

The Truth: The content is the opening act, but the comment section always steals the show. One simple comment can make or break a campaign's impact.

While high-quality content is essential, the engagement within your comments section often determines how memorable and trustworthy your brand is. Timely brand interactions show audiences you’re approachable and listening, which fosters trust. When users feel heard, they’re more likely to view your brand positively, driving loyalty and influencing purchasing decisions. A single, well-crafted reply can spark viral buzz, converting passive viewers into active participants, and reaching audiences beyond your original post.

Real Brand Examples:

• PopFlex: This activewear brand perfectly blends outstanding content with a savvy social listening strategy. From using comments to launch new products to transforming customer feedback into full-fledged campaigns, they’ve mastered the art of connecting with their audience through the comment section. Check out the Instagram post we created to dive deeper into their approach!
  
• Audible: Earlier this year, they replied to a TikTok video about drinking cold-brew concentrate with a witty comment referencing "someone reading at 50x speed," which garnered over 67,000 likes and positive comments from brand fans. This simple interaction turned into a viral moment, showcasing the power of strategic engagement.

Myth #2: “Social media data is just for the marketing team.”

The Truth: Social media insights are valuable across multiple departments—and sharing them can drive impactful business results.

Social platforms are treasure troves of data, offering insights far beyond the social media team. By sharing these insights across departments, brands can inform product development, refine customer service approaches, and optimize sales strategies. This collaborative approach helps businesses make data-driven decisions and stay ahead of competitors.

Real Brand Example:

• e.l.f. Cosmetics: e.l.f.'s "Peculiar Behavior" campaign, centered on their "Skin Bronzing Drops," demonstrates how leveraging social media insights can drive business success across departments. Inspired by TikTok trends emphasizing skincare and wellness, the brand used social listening to inform both product development and marketing strategy. This approach not only aligned their offering with consumer desires but also created a buzzworthy campaign that resonated with their audience. 

• Clinique: The beauty brand is a prime example of how effective social listening and sentiment analysis can drive success. By analyzing UGC, Clinique identified their Black Honey lipstick as a viral product on TikTok. To capitalize on this, they created a dedicated Black Honey playlist, boosting engagement. Their proactive approach also led to the launch of the Black Honey tinted blush, with Clinique responding to a TikTok creator’s post by creating a "stitch" video that has garnered nearly 2M views, showcasing the new product and strengthening their connection with users.

  

Myth #3: “You can’t measure ROI from social media.”

The Truth: Engagement metrics and classification help quantify ROI, even in complex or indirect sales models.

Measuring the ROI of social media communities doesn’t have to rely only on direct sales links. By classifying comments, DMs, and mentions into actionable categories, brands can gain insight into how their social efforts directly influence business outcomes.

Classification in Action:

These classifications provide measurable KPIs, allowing brands to link community engagement to revenue-generating activities like conversions, product improvements, or advocacy-driven sales.

Other Metrics to Measure Social Media ROI:

1. Share of voice (SOV): Compare your brand’s visibility against competitors, including indirect ones, as you're competing for the audience's attention.
2. Mentions of the brand: Use social listening tools to measure how often your brand is talked about in organic conversations.
3. Earned media coverage: Track instances where your social content is referenced by media outlets or influencers.
4. Improved sentiment: Measure how your campaigns impact how positively or negatively your audience perceives your brand.
   
   

In 2024, social media shopping tools (e.g., Instagram and TikTok Shop) delivered a 16% ROI, highlighting their growing impact. Additionally, paid social media content and content marketing each contributed 14% to ROI. (HubSpot State of Marketing)

Myth #4: “Commenting on other people’s posts is cringe or spammy.”

The Truth: Thoughtful, authentic comments build credibility and trust.

It’s easy to think that commenting on posts from other brands or creators might make you look out of place—or worse, spammy. But when done right, it positions your brand as relatable, engaged, and in tune with the latest trends. The key is to add genuine value, whether it’s a witty remark, useful insight, or simply cheering someone on.

When brands move beyond self-promotion and engage authentically, they show they’re listening and care about the broader conversation. This not only increases visibility but also helps to strengthen relationships with your audience, which drives long-term brand affinity.

• Other brand examples:
  

Myth #5: “Comments don’t impact ad performance.”

The Truth: Comments are the secret weapon for improving ad ROI.

Most marketers focus on CTR and conversions, but what happens in your comment section can directly influence how well your ads perform. Negative comments can hurt ad credibility, while positive interactions create trust and increase engagement—ultimately boosting the algorithm’s favor.

Why It Works: Platforms like Meta prioritize engagement in determining ad quality. Active, positive comment sections signal that your ad resonates with the audience, leading to lower ad costs and better reach.

Myth #6: “You should avoid controversial topics to protect your brand.”

The Truth: Addressing important topics thoughtfully can strengthen brand loyalty.

While it’s tempting to steer clear of controversy, brands that stand for something often resonate more with their audiences. The key is to align your message with your brand values and handle sensitive topics with empathy and authenticity.

62% of consumers want companies to take a stand on social, cultural, environmental and political issues close to their hearts (Accenture)

Real Brand Example:

• Ben & Jerry’s: They’ve consistently tackled social issues, from racial justice to climate change, sparking passionate conversations that reinforce their brand identity and build stronger community ties.

Myth #7: “Long-form content doesn’t work on social media.”

The Truth: Longer posts and carousels can drive deeper engagement if done correctly

While short, snappy posts dominate some feeds, long-form content can thrive on platforms like Instagram and LinkedIn. Carousels with up to 20 slides or text-heavy posts often hold users’ attention longer, encouraging saves, shares, and meaningful discussions.

Real Brand Example:

• Nuuly: Rental clothing service Nuuly skillfully tapped into the TikTok Pepe the Prawn trend—a carousel format with several text-heavy slides humorously recounting awkward moments—when responding to a user’s viral subway story involving their rental. The original post has garnered over 8 million views, and Nuuly joined in with a witty, on-brand response using the same format. Their clever engagement demonstrated social savviness, boosted visibility, and made the brand more relatable to audiences.

Why It Works: Instagram’s algorithm prioritizes content that keeps people on the app longer. Long-form posts or carousels that users “hold to read” show strong engagement signals, boosting visibility.

Myth #8: “Sentiment analysis isn’t accurate enough to be useful for brands.”

The Truth: Not all sentiment analysis is created equal—brand-specific analysis delivers actionable insights.

Generic sentiment analysis often misses the mark. Simply labeling a comment as “positive” or “negative” based on language alone doesn’t capture the nuances of customer feedback. That’s why brand-specific sentiment analysis, which focuses on how people feel about your brand—not just the words they use—changes the game.

Why It Matters: Traditional sentiment tools might flag a comment like “I hate how much I love this product” as negative. But with a brand-specific approach, the context shows that this is actually positive sentiment towards your brand. This precision makes the insights actionable, helping you focus on what really matters.

86% of marketers believe that being able to understand a customer’s attitude offers a distinct competitive advantage. (Quid x Adweek)

 

 

Myth #9: “Reviews don’t matter for social media success.”

The Truth: Reviews are a huge trust signal on social media.

People trust reviews as much as personal recommendations, making them essential for building credibility. Sharing positive reviews on social media amplifies your brand's trustworthiness, while addressing negative ones demonstrates a commitment to improvement. Since reviews are often the first point of contact for potential customers, managing them effectively—highlighting positive feedback and responding to criticisms—ensures your brand appears both customer-focused and reliable. This approach not only enhances trust but also fosters stronger customer relationships and loyalty.

88% of consumers say they trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations, and 72% of consumers will take action after reading a positive review. (BrightLocal)

 

 

Myth #10: “All comments should receive equal attention.”

The Truth: Prioritize substantive interactions over emojis.

Not every comment deserves the same response. While short, emoji-only comments can get quick replies, prioritizing detailed or thoughtful interactions adds real value to your brand’s image. This approach encourages meaningful conversations and loyalty.

Real Brand Example:

• Paula's Choice: This skincare brand stands out for its commitment to research and expertise, which shines through in their engagement with customers. They prioritize thoughtful, detailed responses to users seeking skincare advice or sharing feedback. By offering expert insights and engaging in meaningful skincare discussions, Paula’s Choice not only educates but also builds stronger relationships with their community.

  

Why It Works: Thoughtful replies show customers that their voices matter, which builds trust and creates advocates for your brand.

 

Busting Myths, Building Success

Social media marketing in 2025 demands agility, authenticity, and a clear understanding of the ever-evolving digital landscape. By debunking these common myths, we’ve shed light on strategies that drive meaningful engagement, foster trust, and maximize ROI. The key takeaway? A successful social media strategy isn’t about playing it safe or sticking to outdated beliefs—it’s about embracing change, leveraging data, and connecting with audiences on a deeper level. As you refine your approach, remember: the brands that thrive are those that listen, adapt, and engage authentically.